Denture Adhesives Usage in Removable Prosthodontics
Written by Jason Psillakis, DDS, MS
Saturday, 01 March 2003
The full article can be accessed here
Clinical prosthodontics has focused on approaches to improving retention and stability of dentures. In addition to proper fabrication, those approaches have included the use of denture adhesives, retention of a limited number of teeth for overdentures and placement of implants, with the fixtures serving to anchor the prosthesis. In addition, many denture wearers utilize denture adhesives as an over-the-counter approach to improve retention and stability, but the use of these products is not wholly endorsed by the dental profession.1,2
Traditionally, dental education concerning denture prosthesis fabrication has emphasized proper diagnosis and patient evaluation, which includes the examination and impression, an understanding of the mastictory apparatus and occlusion, and then proper laboratory fabrication of complete and partial removable prostheses. Adisman notes that instruction in denture aftercare is generally neglected when compared to the attention given to the steps in treatment that precede delivery of the denture to the patient. It is important that partially edentulous and completely edentulous patients be given instructions concerning the proper use of dentures, including if and when to use denture adhesives.
Table 1. Correct Application of Denture Adhesives (adapted from Adisman1).
The application of denture adhesive to a denture:
(1) The tissue-bearing surface is thoroughly cleansed.
(2) The mucosal surface is cleared of food debris, previous adhesive and saliva.
(3) The adhesive is applied to the undersurface of the denture. Limited amounts are used.
(4) The denture is seated and held firmly in place by hand pressure for 10 seconds.
Dentists who provide prosthodontic services on a regular basis tend to disregard the advantages of using denture adhesives. Often implied here is the perception that the use of adhesives stems from inadequate denture retention, which in turn implies a denture that is not properly fabricated. The clinician may feel that denture adhesive use by a patient is a commentary on his or her clinical skill. In a related sense, a knowledgeable patient who uses a denture adhesive may conclude that their denture was not ideally fabricated.
In contrast to this negative attitude concerning the use of denture adhesives, evidence is now accumulating that these products can be beneficial as part of denture care. With appropriate information and instruction, denture adhesives can, for some patients, improve denture retention and stability without detrimental effects on the mucosa.3-11
As reviewed by Adisman, the use of denture adhesives can be traced back to the end of the 18th century, which coincides with the introduction of modern dental procedures. During the 1800s these products were mixed by apothecaries who used different vegetable and plant gums to yield a mixture that, upon contact with saliva would swell into a mucinous gel that adhered both to the denture and the mucosa. The first patent for a denture adhesive was awarded in 1913, and the ADA referenced adhesives in the 1935 edition of Accepted Dental Remedies.12
Today, denture adhesives are formulated as creams, pastes and powders. Primary constituents include components that promote adhesiveness (ie, karaya gum), antinfective compounds (ie, hexachlorophene), and other agents that improve product characteristics (ie, plasticizers).13 Characteristically, an adhesive should first demonstrate low viscosity, which will allow manipulation and placement. This should be followed by high viscosity, a characteristic that would promote retention.14 An adhesive that always maintains a low viscosity would be poorly retentive; an adhesive that is too viscous would lead to problems with oral hygiene and denture cleanliness.
USE OF DENTURE ADHESIVES IN MODERN PROSTHODONTIC CARE
It is recognized that denture retention in the mouth is the result of the complex interplay of different forces related to local anatomy, patient dependent variables, how the prosthesis is fabricated, and different aspects of surface properties.15,16 Adhesives can improve the retention of the denture to the mucosal surface. This is mediated in part by a thin layer of saliva.
The advantages of increased denture retention and stability observed with denture adhesive use has been confirmed in studies with patients who are new to dentures, as well as patients who have previously worn dentures.4,17-21 The increased retention and stability results in an increase in the force that can be applied during chewing, which translates into fewer strokes to allow swallowing to occur. Other advantages of adhesives include a better distribution of forces on the appliance (which will decrease the formation of ulcers on the mucosal surface), prevention of food debris from accumulating under the denture, and prevention of overgrowth of fungal organisms (Candida albicans).21,5,6,22 Adhesives are recognized as protective of the mucosa, and also aid in proprioception.5,7,8
Furthermore, if used properly, denture adhesives will not increase bone resorption, contribute to adverse changes in the vertical dimensions, or cause any alteration in the activity of muscles of mastication.5,6 Consequently, adhesives deserve to be re-examined as an adjunct to clinical denture care.7,9,23
Characteristics of the ideal adhesive would be a cream that is not irritating and completely biocompatible, without an odor or taste. A cream is preferred to a powder because creams will have a reduced tendency to be washed away in oral fluids.7 Application should be easy, and flow should be minimal so the adhesive remains as placed. The product should also be easily removed form both the denture undersurface and the mucosa. The adhesive properties should remain for 12 to 18 hours. As for patient perception, the ideal adhesive would provide improved retention and stability, leading to improved function during speech, when chewing, and during routine activities (ie, smiling).
Denture adhesives can prove useful during different stages of denture fabrication. These products can also be used during recordings with denture bases. They can also be utilized during the try-in of teeth, as well as during insertion of immediate dentures. Adhesives can be used to provide new denture patients who are concerned with retention with a greater sense of personal security.
CONTRAINDICATIONS FOR THE USE OF DENTURE ADHESIVES
There are a number of reasons why denture adhesives should not be used. An allergy to the adhesive (or component of the adhesive) is an obvious contraindication.24 This allergy may not be recognized until the first time the adhesive is applied under the denture. Inadequate dentures (ie, as a result of mandibular or maxilliary atrophy) should not continue to be used by employing an adhesive. If there is extreme loss of vertical dimension and the soft tissue is poorly formed, new dentures are indicated. In this case, preprosthetic surgery may be needed, and those patients should be evaluated for other approaches to improve retention (ie, osseointegrated implants). Occasionally patients will use excessive amounts of adhesive, which leads to a build-up of hard adhesive on the underside of the denture. Patients should be instructed in the proper use of adhesives. If this does not correct the problem, or the patient cannot clean the adhesive, then use of these products should be discouraged. A damaged or broken denture (ie, flange fracture) should not be retained by using an adhesive. Repair or construction of a new denture is indicated.
The amount of adhesive applied is specific to the individual patient. This is determined by the space between the denture and the mucosa. During application, the amount extruded from the denture borders should be minimal, but some adhesive should be observed.8 The ideal thickness of the layer has been suggested to be 1 mm.25 Information provided by manufacturers can be useful, but patients often learn over time the appropriate amount of adhesive to be used.
For patients who require removable dentures, dentists seek to provide ideal restorations that are retentive and stable, hygienic and aesthetic. Under these conditions, patients should not require denture adhesives as part of denture aftercare.
Nevertheless, as the population ages and patients live longer, and advances in medical care result in more dental patients with multi-system diseases, the profession is likely to treat individuals with extensive ridge resorption who are unable to be seen on a regular basis. This demographic shift suggests the need for re-evaluation of denture adhesives as part of denture care. In fact, new research aimed at development of ideal products is warranted.
A survey of the oral health status of seniors in the United States (65 years and older), based on a study conducted in 1985 to 1986 indicated that only 13% of edentulous seniors had visited the dentist in the past 12 months.26 This percentage, while likely improved since the mid to late 1980s, is quite low, and all individuals should be urged to see the dentist on a regular basis.
Regular oral/dental care for patients with dentures is recommended, both for evaluation of the prostheses, teeth (if present), and mucosal tissues.1,27,28 When needed, denture adhesives can be suggested, but proper instruction on denture aftercare is essential. With this approach, the most appropriate care can be provided.
1. Adisman I. The use of denture adhesives as an aid to denture treatment. J Prosthet Dent. 1989;62:711-715.
2. Grasso J, Rendell J, Gay T. Effect of denture adhesive on the retention and stability of maxillary dentures. J Prosthet Dent. 1994;72:399-405.
3. Yankell SL. Overview of research and literature on denture adhesives. Compend Contin Educ Dent. 1984;(Suppl 4):518-21.
4. Tarbet WJ, Siverman G, Schmidt NF. Maximum incisal biting force in denture adhesives. J Dent Res. 1981;60:115-119.
5. Boone M. Analysis of soluble and insoluble denture adhesives and their relationship to tissue irritation and bone resorption. Compend Contin Educ Dent. 1984;(Suppl 4):S22-S25.
6. Perez P, Kapur KK, Garrett NR. Studies of biological parameters for denture design. Part II: effects of occlusal adjustment, bone retention and fit on masseter muscle activity and mastictory performance. J Prosthet Dent. 1985;53:69-73.
7. Weidner-Strahl SK. Multicenter clinical study of indications for use of denture adhesives. Quintessence. 1984;35:1547-1551.
8. Niedermeier W, Kraft J, Land D. Denture retention by adhesives. A clinical-experimental study. Dtsch Zahndrztl. 1984;39:858-861.
9. Chew LC, Boone ME, Swartz ML, Phillips RW. Denture adhesives: their effect on denture retention and stability. J Dent. 1985;13:152-159.
10. Feller RP, Saunders MJ, Kohut BE. Effect of a new form of adhesive on retention and stability of complete maxillary dentures. Spec Care Dent. 1986;6:87-89.
11. Tarbert WJ, Grossman E. Observations of denture-supporting Observations of denture-supporting tissue during six months of denture adhesive wearing. J Am Dent Assoc. 1980;101:789-791.
12. American Dental Association. Accepted Dental Remedies. Chicago, Ill: American Dental Association; 1935:172.
13. Polytois GL. An update on denture fixatives. Dent Update. 1983;10:579-583.
14. Ellis B, Al-Nakash S, Lamb DJ. The composition and rheology of denture adhesives. J Dent. 1980;8:109-118.
15. Barbenel JC. Physical retention of complete dentures. J Prosthet Dent. 1971;76:592-600.
16. Lindstrom RE, Pawelchak J, Heyd A, Tarbert WJ. Physical-chemical aspects of denture retention and stability: a review of the literature. J Prosthet Dent. 1979;42:371-375.
17. Kapur KK. A clinical evaluation of denture adhesives. J Prosthet Dent. 1967;550-558.
18. Swartz ML, Norman RD, Phillips RW. A method of measuring retention of denture adherents: an in vivi study. J Prosthet Dent. 1967;17:456-463.
19. Stafford GD, Russell C. Efficiency of denture adhesives and their possible influence on oral microorganisms. J Dent Res. 1971;50:832-837.
20. Neill DJ, Roberts BJ. The effect of denture fixatives on masticatory performance in complete denture patients. J Dent. 1972;1:219-222.
21. Tarbet WJ, Boone M, Schmidt NF. Effect of a denture adhesive on complete denture dislodgment during mastication. J Prosthet Dent. 1980;44:374-378.
22. Scher EA, Ritchie GM, Flowers DJ. Antimycotic denture adhesive in treatment of denture stomatitis. J Prosthet Dent. 1978;40:622-627.
23. Chew LC, Phillips RW, Boone ME, Swartz ML. Denture Stabilization with adhesives: a kinesio-graphic study. Compend Contin Educ Dent. 1984;(Suppl 4):S32-S38.
24. Hogan WJ. Allergic reaction of adhesive denture powders. NY State Dent J. 1954;20:65.
25. Benson D, Rothman RS, Sims TN. The effect of a denture adhesive on the oral mucosa and vertical dimension of complete denture patients. J S Cal Dent Assoc. 1972;40:468-473.
26. Key Dental Facts. American Dental Association. 2002;8:19.
27. Dentist’s Desk Reference: Materials, Instruments and Equipment. Chicago, Ill: American Dental Association; 1981:345.
28. Dentist’s Desk Reference: Materials, Instruments and Equipment. Chicago, Ill: American Dental Association; 1981:423.